All-College Writing Contest


All-College Writing Contest Winner

Document Type


Date of Award


Author Comments

Although my essay was written for Professor Lombardi's course on the philosophy of law, Affirming the Individual represents a more intimate effort than its detached academic analysis would suggest. Having worked in the Lake Forest College Admissions Office for nearly two years, I was a bit wary at first of writing about the policies of preferential treatment. Remembering the courtesy, fairness, and personal concern with which my own admission was handled, a certain anxiety crept over me as I contemplated a critique of the very system that had been so amenable to me. My apprehensions were allayed, however, as my research expanded and my critical eye turned to a more abstract consideration of the issues surrounding my argument. Rather than an outright condemnation of discernible preferential treatment, my paper is instead a comparative assessment of plausible policies of preference as they relate to admission and hiring practices. Furthermore, I take my interpretation and understanding of the College's admission practices as a model for this comparison. As such, the staff at Patterson Lodge deserves my gratitude for the inside knowledge I have gained in their employ. I also unconditionally praise their collective sympathy for the ageless timecrunch dilemma faced by all students at one time or another. Without this show of compassion, I would not have been able to write. 49



To view the content in your browser, please download Adobe Reader or, alternately,
you may Download the file to your hard drive.

NOTE: The latest versions of Adobe Reader do not support viewing PDF files within Firefox on Mac OS and if you are using a modern (Intel) Mac, there is no official plugin for viewing PDF files within the browser window.